The Herringbone Nightstand: Alternative Wins

This pair sells itself on a plain fact: you literally cannot buy the original new anymore. RH discontinued its Herringbone Closed Nightstand, so the $1,422 below is the last confirmed price, not a listing. Modus Furniture's Alexandra is a real furniture-maker piece with a genuine herringbone inlay, at a third of that price — warmer in tone and 3″ shallower, but the look, buyable today.

	The Name: RH Herringbone Closed Nightstand	The Alternative: Modus Alexandra Two Drawer Nightstand (Rustic Latte)
Price	$1,422 (last confirmed — discontinued, no live listing)	$458
You save	—	$964 against the last confirmed price
Construction	Hand-pieced oak herringbone set within mitered frames, weathered grey oak finish, touch-latch drawers, ~102 lbs	Solid acacia planks, sanded, stained and whitewashed for a driftwood look, inlaid over plywood in a genuine herringbone pattern; full-extension ball-bearing glides, English dovetail drawer boxes, ~59 lbs
Size	30″W × 20″D × 24″H	30″W × 17″D × 24″H — same width and height, 3″ shallower
Owner record	Resale pairs have sold out	No pooled review count could be verified — none is claimed here; the spec sheet carries the case (dovetail boxes and ball-bearing glides are the two details cheap nightstands fake first, and both are specified)

Prices checked by hand on October 24, 2026 at Skylar's Home & Patio; the RH price is the last confirmed figure, not a live listing — prices move with sales, confirm before you buy.

Our verdict: the alternative wins. With the original discontinued, this isn't a value judgment so much as the only door still open — and it's a good door. The Alexandra is made by a real furniture maker, not a no-name flat-pack, and its dimensions match RH's exactly except depth. The honest catch: Rustic Latte reads warmer and browner than RH's weathered grey oak, so it's close, not a color clone — and at 17″ deep, measure your lamp base before you buy.

Where the money goes

The inlay: both nightstands are genuinely herringbone — pieced wood, not a printed pattern. That's the whole look, and the Modus piece doesn't fake it.
The weight gap: ~59 lbs against ~102 lbs. The RH piece is a heavier, denser build; the Modus is lighter because its inlay sits over plywood. You feel it when you move it, not when you look at it.
What the original's absence means: resale pairs have sold out, so there's no "wait for a used one" play either. If you want this look beside your bed, the Alexandra is the buy.

See the alternative at Skylar's Home & Patio

The RH original is discontinued — there is no original buy link on this page, and we won't link a resale listing as a buy target.

Dopperly may earn a commission from purchases made through links on this page, at no cost to you. Full disclosure. We are never paid to change a verdict.