The Kentfield Pendant: Alternative Wins

Two corrections to the shortlist, stated first, because both change the math: the Kentfield Pendant is not $798 — the Large (24″W × 34″H, six Type C candelabra bulbs) is $1,698 — and it is not solid brass, it's steel. Only the Large is six-light; the Small and Medium are four-light. So the real comparison is a $1,698 six-light steel lantern against open-frame candelabra pendants — and a steel dupe is not a material downgrade from a steel original.

	The Name: Serena & Lily Kentfield Pendant, Large	The Alternative: Wayfair Dumas 6-Light Lantern Geometric Chandelier (Steelside)
Price	$1,698 Large, six-light	$604 (seen at $573.80 on sale; the $269.99 figure from grading is no longer found)
You save	—	$1,094
Construction	Steel with a choice of finish, open rectangular lantern frame with no glass, candelabra bulbs on an architectural base, 6-foot chain, 6″ ceiling plate, hardwired, dimmer-compatible	Open lantern frame, no glass, candelabra base holding six lights up to 60W each (bulbs sold separately), down rod and circular canopy compatible with sloped ceilings, dimmer-compatible; 4.6★ from 112–113 votes
Size and lights — match these	Large: 24″W × 34″H, six lights. Small (12.5″W × 18″H) and Medium (17″W × 24.5″H) are four-light, not six-light.	Six lights, same open-frame candelabra form. A four-light dupe hung where the six-light Large belongs will look dimmer and smaller — count the lights and measure before you buy.
Owner record	—	Wayfair owners of the 6-light open-lantern class praise the look over islands and in entries, with the usual budget-fixture caveats of assembly effort and finish varying by batch

Prices checked by hand on October 24, 2026 at Serena & Lily (via roundup coverage confirming $1,698) and Wayfair; prices move with sales — confirm before you buy.

Our verdict: the alternative wins — if you match light count and size. Because the fixture is essentially a steel frame, there is little hidden engineering to cheap out on — the finish is the look, and it's visible from across the room, not under hand. The honest catch: cheap gold paint can read brassy up close, so if the gilded finish is the point, inspect it in daylight on arrival — and never substitute a four-light fixture for the six-light Large.

Where the money goes

The finish: what Serena & Lily alone has is gilded finish quality and scale consistency — notably the 24″ × 34″ Large. A budget gold can read brassy; matte black is the safer finish if you're unsure.
The lights: six candelabra bulbs vs four is not a footnote — it's the brightness of the room. This is the single most common way a Kentfield dupe disappoints, and it's entirely avoidable by counting before checkout.
The steel surprise: the original is steel, not solid brass as the roundups claimed. That removes the one material argument for paying $1,698 — a steel frame at $604 is the same engineering at a third of the price.

See the alternative at Wayfair

No verbatim Serena & Lily product URL for the Kentfield Pendant was verified, so there is no original buy link on this page — search "Kentfield Pendant" at serenaandlily.com and pick the Large six-light size, not just the name.

Dopperly may earn a commission from purchases made through links on this page, at no cost to you. Full disclosure. We are never paid to change a verdict.